Policy’s Employer Liability Bar Nixes Coverage for Fatal Accident
By Don R. Sampen, published, Chicago Daily Law Bulletin, November 3, 2026
The 1st District Appellate Court recently held that the term “employee” as used in a liability insurance policy would be given its plain meaning, and as such, an exclusion applicable to an employer’s liability for employee bodily injury relieved the insurer of any duty to indemnify.
The case is Mt. Hawley Insurance Co. v. Stone Development Group, Inc., 2026 IL App (1st) 250465 (Sept. 30). The insurer, Mt. Hawley, was represented by Tressler LLP of Chicago. Cogan & Power P.C. of Chicago represented the claimant, the administrator of the estate of Ramiro Godinez, the deceased employee.
Stone Development Group (SDG) was a carpentry subcontractor for the construction of a hotel in Waukegan in 2017. Prior to commencing the work, SDG’s vice president and director of construction, John Stone, hired several carpenters and asked one of them, Andre Becerra, if he knew of other available workers. Becerra then brought Godinez with him to the construction site on the first day of work.
At the beginning of the day, a forklift was used to hoist tools to the third floor of the project. When Godinez attempted to retrieve the tools, he fell 20 feet to the ground; he later died of his injuries.
The estate subsequently sued SDG and ultimately reached a settlement that was to be paid in large part from Mt. Hawley, SDG’s general liability carrier. Mt. Hawley provided a defense for SDG in the lawsuit but denied any indemnity coverage based on the policy’s employer liability exclusion.
That exclusion applied to any liability of SDG for bodily injury to its employees. SDG had no workers’ compensation insurance coverage at the time of the accident.
Mt. Hawley brought a declaratory judgment action to determine its obligation to pay indemnity.
The estate argued that Godinez never actually became an employee. Mt. Hawley, however, took the position that Stone offered employment to both Becerra and Godinez “as a conduit.” Stone at first said Godinez was an employee, but after he learned Mt. Hawley had denied coverage, Stone changed his position.
Following a bench trial, and relying on a dictionary definition of “employee,” the trial court held Godinez was an employee and that the exclusion applied. The estate then appealed.
Analysis
In an opinion by Justice Clare J. Quish, the 1st District affirmed. She initially addressed the estate’s argument regarding the definition of “employee” as used in the policy. It contended that the term was defined only such that it included a “leased worker” but did not include a “temporary worker.” Given such an inadequate definition, the estate argued the term should be interpreted in favor of coverage.
Quish observed, however, that under Illinois law, where a term is undefined, it is to be afforded its plain, ordinary and popular meaning — the court would look to a dictionary definition.
As such, Quish determined that the trial court properly applied the Black’s Law Dictionary definition to the effect that an employee is one who works in the service of another under an express or implied contract where the employer controls the details of work performance.
Before determining whether Godinez was, in fact, an employee, Quish addressed the admissibility of an Occupational Safety and Health Administration report on the accident that regarded Becerra as an employee of SDG who, in turn, recruited Godinez. She found that the report was properly admitted into evidence by the trial court under Rule of Evidence 803(8)(c), which provides for the admission of public reports containing factual findings from an authorized investigation.
As for Godinez’s status as an employee, Quish found that the evidence at trial was mixed in that Stone did not directly speak to Godinez, and that Godinez received no training or orientation about the job. Stone did, however, instruct Becerra and Godinez to meet with the foreman on the job, and Stone included Godinez in a list of SDG employees after the accident. Stone also repeatedly represented to OSHA that Godinez was an employee. It was only later, after Mt. Hawley denied coverage, that Stone changed his position.
Based on this evidence Quish concluded that the trial court’s finding of an employment relationship was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
The estate also made several other arguments. One was that Godinez did not actually perform any work for SDG. Quish pointed out, however, that Godinez was on the construction site to perform work for SDG before his death and had been preparing to start work. Stone and Becerra also arranged for Godinez to start that day, and the foreman had instructed Becerra and Godinez to go to the third floor.
Thus, even if Godinez was not following the specific instructions he was given and had not started performing carpentry work, there was sufficient evidence that he was working for SDG at the time of his death.
The court therefore affirmed the judgment in favor of Mt. Hawley that the employer liability exclusion applied.
Key Points
- Undefined words in an insurance policy are to be given their plain, ordinary and popular meaning, such as may be found in a dictionary.
- Someone hired to perform work on a job may be considered an employee even if the person has not actually begun to perform the work.
Don R. Sampen